Why is it unsurprising? Well, I've been fairly career-focused for a few decades now, and was reasonably supporting myself for quite a while before I met my husband. And until we moved into our current house, I never lived anywhere I couldn't pay for myself or with roommates. So, I was in a situation in which what I made was sufficient to pay all my bills, and even if I didn't always make the best financial decisions, still, I was in many senses a self-supporting unit. I didn't feel confident about it, struggled with feelings of insecurity, inadequacy, and guilt among others, due to large bills, a tendency to spend when I shouldn't, and self-judgement. However, I also felt pride in my eventual success in pulling myself out of the hole I'd gotten into, becoming self-supporting, and running my own business. And in this society, legitimacy is conferred, mainly, by monetary success.
Then I met my husband. We got fairly quickly into a serious relationship, bought a house, got married, and then had a baby. Now I'm in a house I actually couldn't afford on my own, even with tenants (the NW real estate market being what it is), and my income will always (most likely) be a small fraction of his. I would certainly struggle to keep afloat if it were just me and my daughter.
Interestingly, I think that were I married to a fellow income-challenged artist, I would not feel the same way, because I wouldn't be making the comparisons I do between my income and that of my husband. So, it would seem that I feel inadequate only in comparison to someone else, that my legitimacy as an income-producing member of society is to be judged along a financial heirarchy.
Now, there are all sorts of reasons separate from money why my job has importance, relevance, and matters to more people than just me. I am a teacher, and can see that I bring positives to other people's lives. I have the reward of ongoing rich relationships with my students. I get to see them develop over a period of years. I learn from them and they learn from me, and I am glad to be able to do what I do for a living.
Now, however, I am home much more than I used to be, and when I am home my days are very different than they used to be. It's hard to get much done in between feeding, changing, playing with, and caring for my daughter. Sometimes it's hard at the end of the day even to remember what happened that day, because sometimes the days take on a certain sameness. I do dishes, I pump milk, I feed the baby, I eat, I usually get out for a walk, I feed the baby, I answer a bit of email (on which I'm behind), I eat, I feed the baby....etc. In a world in which production and external success count for so much, there are mere crumbs in my tally which would count for anything at all in the definition of some.
So, what is legitimacy? Is it internally derived, or externally conferred? On the first gut-check, it would seem obvious that there has to be some degree of externality to it: otherwise, a person could declare anything a legitimate way to spend time. It's easy to think of examples worthy of scorn, pity, or just a confused scratch on the head....the guy who spends all his time in his parents' basement doing nothing but eating pizza and playing online games, for example, or the woman who, ... but I cringe; the rest of my brain is already castigating me: who am I to judge the value or worth of other people's time, their lives? Really, I can't. I can have feelings about it, or even opinions, but I cannot know the realities of the interior of someone's mind and heart. I do not want to place myself in superior position and say that someone's life is not, in essence, worth living. That's a spiritual weight I'd rather forego.
So, let's check the dictionary for some help.
From Merriam/Webster, online:
Main Entry: le·git·i·ma·cy
Pronunciation: \li-ˈji-tə-mə-sē\
Function: noun
Date: 1691
Def: : the quality or state of being legitimate.
Well, ok. hmmm. Let's go see what they say about "legitimate".
Main Entry: le·git·i·mate
Pronunciation: \li-ˈji-tə-mət\
Function: adjective
Etymology: Middle English legitimat, from Medieval Latin legitimatus, past participle of legitimare to legitimate, from Latin legitimus legitimate, from leg-, lex law
Date: 15th century
Definitions:
1 a: lawfully begotten ; specifically : born in wedlock b: having full filial rights and obligations by birth
2: being exactly as purposed : neither spurious nor false
3 a: accordant with law or with established legal forms and requirements b: ruling by or based on the strict principle of hereditary right
4: conforming to recognized principles or accepted rules and standards
5: relating to plays acted by professional actors but not including revues, burlesque, or some forms of musical comedy
Alright. Number 1 doesn't apply here. So strike issues of, well, legitimate issue. :-)
Number 2 seems more applicable: I am what I say I am, a teacher. But I am teaching less, devoting more time and energy to mothering my baby, and to domestic chores. So, my connection to that sense of professional identity, while there, is less clear and strong than it used to be. Ok, in order to be legitimate, do I have to be who I say I am? Is it identity?
Number 3 also doesn't seem to apply here, except that my legitimacy as a teacher has something (maybe everything, but certainly a lot) to do with how my students view and experience me. After all, if they learned nothing from me I couldn't be viewed as legitimately teaching. I'd just be wasting oxygyn.
Number 4 is interesting. Accepted standards? Accepted rules? Of society? Well, so often that it's still the norm for significant chunks of society, the woman in a heterosexual partnership winds up in a position similar to mine upon the advent of children. So yeah, this is usual, accepted, and, by many, expected. So, given that externally no one would question my legitimacy as a mother/domestic worker (snark), why would I feel any oddness here? It appears to have to do with my own feelings of legitimacy, based in my background and upbringing, life experience, and values. So, a mixture of the external and internal. The rules by which I live are not mainstream, and that has everything to do with by whom and where I was brought up, as well, I think, as my own inherent personality and desires. I never really thought I'd have children, and when I thought about it, I didn't imagine that I'd be spending the sheer quantity of time that I am now in a non-professional setting. So, I've in some sense gone against my own set of "rules" or expectations.
Number 5, again, doesn't really apply except in the sense that we're all actors on the stage of life... (hee hee)
This definition is all externally-driven. It says nothing about identity, or self-defined reality. What I come back to in the end, then, is that I think that legitimacy does have an external component, but that ultimately the most important thing by far is whether I think that what I'm doing conforms with my values. So, does it?
Yes: I value living with courage, integrity, truthfulness, and love. Bringing up a child with love is something I consider to be deeply important and valuable. Ultimately, I have to be careful not to mix together two things which, though related in some way are separate issues: 1) my sense of identity, and 2) the legitimacy of my actions as they relate to my values. My sense of identity has been intertwined for a long time with my professional identity and life. I am seeing now that I need to expand and flex that identity. I know that I will, and am confident that I'll be able to absorb all the newness which has come my way. My lifelong commitment is to align my actions with my values, and I know also that, though there will be plenty of mistakes along the way, I'll do that too, because it is of extreme importance to me.
This does not mean that I'll kick up my heels and lightly brush away any care of what anyone else thinks of me; I am not at this point tempermentally able to do that. However, this whole thought process is a reminder to me that what matters to me the most is my own internal compass, and following my truth is the way for me to adhere to my sense of legitimacy.
That, and the knowledge that every dawn is a new day, and if I feel compelled to start a new career sometime down the road, well, I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.




